Sunday, March 04, 2007

Investing Resource Review: Online - Discount Stock Brokers


This weekend Barrons has the annual issue out which reviews the online/discount brokers. While it does a good job overall, I think it misses some specific aspects of brokers that new investors are looking for.

This time last year I was looking for a stockbroker and found it a bit confusing as to which one might be best for me. As a new investor what I craved most of all was access to information and research. And I wanted it in a cost effective manner.

So I did a bit of reading and came up with a list of stockbrokers that might appeal to new investors who are looking for professional research for the least amount of money. In fact, what I found is that it is pretty easy and essentially free to get research services that others might pay several hundreds of dollars to receive.

For those who already are happy with their broker it is easy to access these brokers in a manner that does not require moving your current account. Moreover, the list may appeal to the more active trader who has an account at one of the brokers that start at only a $1-2 per trade (MB Trading and Interactive Brokers). The active trader gains access to research not available with their primary stockbroker who was selected for different reasons.

I limited my research to online stock brokers who do not charge any fees for account activity or any fee to maintain an IRA. Why? Because most new investors either do not trade actively and/or opening an IRA will be the way they begin to invest. Also, because these accounts may be secondary accounts holding down costs is important. Moreover, I wanted this list to be relevant for the more experienced investor who is looking to access different research sources without having to commit large amounts of capital to a secondary account and worry about maintaining a certain level of activity. Furthermore, I only included brokers that actually offered some type of third party research for no additional charge to account holders.

This only left eight online or discount stock brokers out of over 50 that I checked. I ranked them based on 1. amount of research offered; 2. trade cost; and 3. minimum amount to open. Here is what I found.

Coming in at No. 8 is Accutrade. Stock Trades are $29.95. Minimum to open is $2,000. Research includes Institutional Shareholder Services, S&P Stock Reports, and Bob Gabele's Insider Trading Watch.

Pros: No account fees
Cons: $29.95 for a trade; $2,000 to open; $29.95 for a trade; limited research; $29.95 for a trade

Bottom Line: Did I mention $29.95 for a trade? That alone stops me. Throw in the $2,000 minimum to open, limited research, and the lackluster website and I am no way Jose on this one.


Tied at No. 6-7 is Scottrade. Scottrade offers $7.00 stock trades. $500.00 minimum to open with no account fees. Research includes: S&P Reports and Thomson Financial.

Pros: $7.00 trades; many local office locations; no account fees
Cons: $500.00 to open and limited research

Bottom Line: If you want/need to be able to walk in and talk to your broker than Scotttrade is for you, as it has many physical branches nationwide. $7.00 trades are a plus but limited research holds me back.

Tied at No. 6-7 is Firstrade. Firsttrade offers $6.95 stock trades. No minimum to open and no account activity or IRA fee. S&P Reports are offered.

Pros: $6.95 stock trades, no minimum to open; no account fee
Cons: Only offers S&P reports

Bottom Line: Good pricing on stock trades at $6.95 and no minimum to open get it tied with Scottrade, but very limited research makes it a no go in my book.


No. 4-5 is E*Trade. Etrade offers $12.99 stock trades. The available research includes Reuters Research, S&P Reports, Rochdale Research, Sabrient Systems, Wall Street On Demand, Thomson Financial, and Bank of New York’s Jaywalk Research Reports. For those with large accounts ($100,000+) Credit Suisse Research is also available. You can find the whole list here.

Pros: Wide offering of research providers; no fee IRA accounts
Cons: $12.95 stock trades; $1,000 minimum to open; non-IRA accounts must make at least one trade per quarter or are assessed $40 account charge

Bottom Line: At first glance looks inviting based on the amount of research available, but the $40 account charge on non-IRA accounts and $1,000 minimum to open puts me off. $12.95 for trades is also a negative. Objectively it could be higher, but hey it is my list and I just get the feeling that it is more of a bank with a lot of little fees here and there.


Tied No. 4-5. is Optionsxpress. Optionsxpress offers stock trades for $14.95 with no minimums to open and no account fees. Optionxpress provides free access to Morningstar stock reports.

Pros: Morningstar research; good tools for option traders; no minimum to open, no fees on any account
Cons: Stock trades are $14.95; only offers Morningstar stock research

Bottom Line: No hidden fees at all is a big plus as is no minimum to open, but $14.95 for stock trades is a negative (if the trade cost was under $10 I would have put them at No. 3). While it is limited in research to Morningstar Stock Reports it is the only broker to offer access to Morningstar so that gives it a slight edge to E*Trade in my book. Note: For those interested in Health Savings Accounts (HSA) Optionsxpress is one of the very few ways you can actually set up an HAS account and trade normally.


No. 3 is Muriel Seibert. Trades are $14.95. No minimum to open and no account fee except on IRA’s less than $10,000 ($30 per year). Seibert offers the following research: Standard & Poor's Reports, Zacks Research, Reuter’s Multex, ProphetFinance, Validea, MarketEdge®, VectorVest®, Growth Stock Analytics, Lehman Brothers, and Thomson Baseline.

Pros: No minimum to open, wide variety of research
Cons: $14.95 to trade, $30 a year on IRAs less than $10,000

Bottom Line: Good selection of research. $14.95 to trade is a negative as is the $30 per year charge on a IRA. But it offers a wide variety of research with a couple of unique products not offered elsewhere. If there is some specific research provided which is something you are looking for than this may be the choice for you. It gets the nod over E*Trade based on no minimum to open and over Optionsxpress based on the amount of research. If Seibert cut its trade cost and got rid of the $30 IRA account fee it could challenge for the top two spots.

No. 2 is Fidelity. Fidelity has stock trades for $19.95. There is a $2,500 minimum to open but no account fees. Research is extensive: Argus Research, Ativo Research, LLC, Channel Trend, Columbine Capital Services, Decision Economics, Ford Equity Research, Lehman Brothers, Market Edge, Ned Davis Research , Prudential Equity Group, Standard & Poor's Reports and Outlook, Thomas White International, Thomson Financial, and Zacks Research .

Pros: Lots of Research, No account fees, local branches
Cons: Trades are $19.95, $2,500 minimum to open

Bottom Line: While the trade price is high at $19.95, the amount of available research makes Fidelity one to consider. Also, many investors might have a 401(k) here and that may make it easier to keep everything in one spot. The trade cost and large minimum to open kept it out of first place.


The No 1 pick is TDAmeritrade. Stock trades are $9.99. Minimum to open is $1,000 for IRA accounts and $2,000 non-IRA. Research includes : S&P Reports and Outlook, Vickers Stock Research, Thomson’s First Call, The Street.com Ratings, Ford Equity Research, and Thomson’s Market Edge.

Pros: $9.99 stock trades, lots of research, no account fees
Cons: $1,000/$2,000 minimum to open

Bottom Line: TDAmeritrade offers good selection of research and a low trade price. While the minimum to open is a drawback, overall I would say TDAmeritrade deserves consideration and gets a slight nod over Fidelity based on the trade cost.

In the end I like Fidelity for the selection of research and if I based it solely on that I would say that it would be No. 1. But TDAmeritrade is no slouch in research and offers a trade cost half as much as Fidelity’s so it gets the nod as No. 1, but just barely.

Overall, any one of these brokers is a good deal, and my 1-5 are all solid choices. While I have ranked them as a means of separating them relative to each other, they all provide more value than they ask for. That is because anyone of the brokers is offering several hundred dollars worth of research just to open an account, in some cases with no minimum, and at no annual cost. Pretty good bargain for any investor.

58 comments:

Anonymous said...

This post is wonderful. I had a very hard time finding the right brokerage firm for online trading and just last week decided to open an account with TD Ameritrade.
Thanks again, I appreciate the work you put in compiling this list.
P.S.: I am also glad we came to the same conclusion. ;-)

Anonymous said...

Hi, I'm the author of the annual Barron's review. The brokers are reviewed with an eye towards which ones best serve experienced investors (your typical Barron's reader) who has at least $100,000 to put into an account.

It's specifically not geared to beginning traders. It would be a very different review if that was the case.

My story does, however, discuss the quality of the trading technology. Some of the extremely cheap brokers are ripping you off when it comes to executing your trade. Your "free" trade could be costing you 1/4 or 1/2 of a point due to inefficient routing, or routing that puts the broker's best interest in mind rather than the trader's (internalizing the order, receiving payment for order flow).

FYI, Scottrade just opened up a new research center that ought to put it much higher on your list.

Once you make 10 trades at optionsXpress, your commissions drop to $9.95 per transaction.

Steven said...

Markus: Thanks

Theresa: Oh I did not mean to imply that I did not like your article. I actually selected my broker last year based on your article, so I must say your review (and other articles you write) is most helpful.

Obviously I do not have the time and space constraints that you have nor do I have any need to focus on anything but my own interest.

My review was not meant to serve as a substitute for yours; on the contrary, I had hoped my review would serve as an additional tool for new investors looking for research at a low cost.

Anonymous said...

Nice review.

You could also go to Vegas and lose money there. LOL

Unknown said...

Gret work. Another online broker you should add to your list is TradeKing (www.tradeking.com). They have better pricing than any of the entrants on your list and still earned the highest 4 Star rating from Barron's--great tools and service for less! Check 'em out.

Tom

Steven said...

Thomas:

I did not include Tradeking because they do not offer any research.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the helpful information.

When choosing a broker, I find tax lot accounting and dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP) to be two other features worth considering. When I was a newbie investor, I couldn't care less about them, but now I do. Some brokers offer both features for free; for example, my broker, TD Ameritrade, recently started doing so. Tax lot accounting will save me lots of time during tax season. I have not tried DRIP yet.

One thing I don't like about TD Ameritrade is, although they don't charge account maintenance fee, they do have many other little service fees, such as for early IRA distribution and full/partial outbound account transfer, that limit my flexibility.

Anonymous said...

A really helpful post, finding a good online discount stock broker can be a real pain and this article is really helpful.

Stock Investing for Beginner Site.

Roger Overanout

India Job Updates said...

The most important thing that would entice you to use these online stock brokers is their commission rates. These online stock brokers charge very low commission rates, as compared to any other human stock brokers. The only thing you need to do is to find a good one by using some search engines in the internet. Compare their commission rates and also consider the other aspects. Finally select the one that suits all your needs well. I found stock market investing at $3 per trade to be cheap.
Sogo also offers fractional share trading.

Anonymous said...

The $40 quarterly account fee she claims E*Trade assesses is not quite the whole story. Numerous situations allow said fee to be waived. While I didn't expect the article to list each condition, it would have been more helpful to at least mention that some conditions allowed that fee to be bypassed.

Anonymous said...

I have Fidelity. However, the research is bogus as it is with almost all the discount brokers. They use so called "third party" research firms who do nothing more than crunch numbers according to some weird algorithm. There is no substitute for real direct and timely research from the likes of full service firms like J. P. Morgan, Citigroup, Morgan Keegan Stifel Nicholas, etc.

All you get with the discounter is better brokerage rates and poor research that is most of the time stale and not timley. They do not visit or analyze companies or even call the companies up. Belive me, I know, since I listen in on many earnings conference calls with companies right along side the analysts for the major firms. None of the "third party" researchers are even on the phone to ask questions. Nobody including Columbine, Ativo, etc. They are bogus.

Therefore the"research" the dicounters offer is bogus. NOne of the major firms that do real research will ever give their research over to these discounters. You get what you pay for.

Penny Stocks said...

Great post with very useful information. Thanks.

Penny Stocks said...

Great idea! I am going to give your plugin a shot. Thanks

Penny Stocks said...

Nice blog.Thanks for information.

Penny Stocks said...

Excellent information. This sounds exactly like what I've been looking for.

Penny Stocks said...

The blog posting is really good & attractive.For which people can like it.

Medyum Hoca said...

Excellent information. This sounds exactly like what I've been looking for.

Luke 'the stock market investing' guy said...

When selecting a broker it is important not to put too much emphasis on brokerage. Brokerage is but one part of selecting a broker. Other important factors include: research tools, reliability (i.e. are you able to execute trades when you need to), accessibility (i.e. how many different ways can you contact the broker), complaint and resolution process, etc.

Penny Stocks said...

Your posts, are awesome....
very well written...i am one of your regular readers...

Penny Stocks said...

Fantastic article. Thanks so much for your insight and example.

Penny Stocks said...

Very informative blog,lots of great info

Unknown said...

Zecco Trading is also very good for stock options trading. Option strategies are easy to enter and generally get good, quick fills. Customer Service is a bit cumbersome, but I haven't seen any broker that rivals their option strategies ability.
You can learn more about stock options here ...

Penny Stocks said...

A really helpful post, finding a good online stocks.

Penny Stocks said...

Good post.....Valuable information for all.I will recommend my friends to read this for sure…

Penny Stocks said...

oh!what a great writing style..i really appreciate your blog..well done

Penny Stocks said...

thanks for the great blog post it helped me a lot. keep sharing and the good work!

http://www.pennystockteam.com said...

i appreciate all the helpful information that you gave i really liked it. help me to learn more thank you.

Penny Stock Picks said...

Great help thank you very much.

Penny Stock Forum

penny stock said...

Most of organizations promoting top penny stocks are probably involved in some kind of scheme to flat out rip you off through a scheme called chop stocks or use you to inflate the value of stocks to execute the pump and dump scheme.

Daily Stock Picks said...

I am looking for an undiscovered security from a list of Daily Stock Picks. What is the best option to find daily stocks picks?

GilBurt said...

Thank you very much for all these fantastic resources.

ENTB

GilBurt said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Stock Picks said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along.

ENTB

Loan express said...

These brokers give discount which is good for the people who are dealing with them

SMC Global said...

Thanks for the mention!!!Really i got informative post about the discount brokers as you define.You can also check the Online Stock Broker trends.

ex dividend date said...

great post and you should check out some stocks if you plan on day trading for a living

Payday Loans said...

I wonder how brokers give discount.how they earn and how they give discount.

Goa Escorts said...

After reading your post,I am really worried of this coming meltdown situation.Thanks for such awarding post.

Will C. said...

Hi, my name is Will and I was just browsing your stock resources page.

I work for Marc Chaikin at Chaikin Stock Research. Marc has been a recognized expert in stock analysis for more than 40 years and is best known for creating the widely-used Chaikin Oscillator and Chaikin Persistency of Money Flow, the basis of Investor’s Business Daily’s Accumulation/Distribution Rating.

Last year, Marc founded a free resource for analyzing stocks called the "Chaikin Power Gauge". This gauge lets you get an easy-read red/green (Bullish or Bearish) rating on any of 5000 stocks based on his proprietary model.

Would you take a look at www.chaikinpowertools.com and consider listing us as a resource for stock research?

Thank you, and I appreciate your time!

- Will C., Chaikin Stock Research

penny stocks to watch said...

Great post and incredibly helpful. Finding a discount broker is incredibly important when it comes to trading, the lower the commissions the higher the profit.

I too covered the topic regarding
penny stock brokers

Investing stocks said...

I have not been this thrilled by a blog post for quite some time! You’ve got it, whatever that means in blogging. Anyway, You’re definitely someone that has something to say that people should hear.

swetha said...

Stock Options Strategies

Thanks much for the resources. It cannot deliver all that stock brokers can but useful for the necessities that it provides.

Unknown said...


We’re all about fresh, healthy, calorie- witting food. Our absolutely allotted meals are designed to meet your nutritionary needs, whilst still following even the most recognizing palate. While our healthy eating plans are great for weight loss, they should not be dismissed as ‘just another weight loss diet. Our high quality meals are not based on celebrity fad diets; they are made from real ingredients in consultation with experienced dietitians. If you’re searching for great tasting, healthy weight loss meal plans, we have a selection that comes in under 450 calories. Of course, our meals are not just designed for those wanting to slim down – they are also designed to support optimal physical health, and are therefore perfect for those looking to maintain a healthy weight.
See My Partners website for future bookings:

health food
high fiber biscuits
sugar free biscuits
sugar free Rusk
healthy snacks
controlled diet

Unknown said...

Hello, enthusiasts that are beloved. I adore what I reveal and do it. Behind-closed-doors this refined, clever woman becomes a sexy seductress. Collectively we are going to go when a couple have an all-natural biochemistry together to the levels of joy that may only be achieved. We will…
For More Information go Our website :

Independent Goa Escorts agency
Escorts In Goa

Unknown said...

Hi. My name is top-notch company in Warsaw for minutes that are memorable, Martina. I favor to dress stylishly with highheels and have an astonishing body that is tasteful with hot contours. I'm quite enthusiastic and enchanting, stylish, openminded, easygoing, ideal company for…
Visit our Website to book:
Jaipur Escorts Service
Female Escorts In Jaipur

Unknown said...

I will be not UNREAL! My pictures are genuine. For challenging men really high class company. Best means to invest your time - appeal, sex, sophistication - rest the mind and ruin the human body. Therefore please, don't loose your opportunity to have the greatest…
Open this link :
Independent Escorts In Mumbai
Mumbai Escort

Unknown said...

With long-ish light brown hair and green eyes that are amazing is Victoria a gorgeous Polish attractiveness. She's very hot and quite quite really. She's a great approach helpful and really interesting and sexy. She is interesting and quite sexy.… and has an excellent atmosphere about her
See the my personal website:
Independent Mumbai Escorts Service
Mumbai Female Escorts

Unknown said...

Redirects an offer for guys trying to find a professional massage practitioners that are good as well as appealing. Embrace in private in a cozy environment that is very amorous. Massage to the table. I encourage You Welcome to the area of easiness. We encourage one to massage Human Anatomy to…
See My Partners website for future bookings:
Mumbai Escorts Service
Independent Mumbai Escorts

Unknown said...

We tend to called the most successful provider of such enjoy able infatuated women. They Are not exc lusively stunning however they are daring and good.

Chandigarh Escort Service
Escort In Chandigarh
Chandigarh Escort

Lucknow Escort Service In Call Girls said...

Myself Avantika rao,I am one of top Lucknow escorts available for who looking from 1 hour dinner dates to Overnight and longer.I am genuine escorts with genuine photos so that you will get the girl you have seen where available.

Lucknow Call Girls
Escort In Lucknow
Call Girls In Lucknow

Escort Service In Lucknow
Call Girls In Lucknow
Lucknow Call Girls
Dehradun Escort Service

Aarvi Mehtha said...

To our universe we left next program and after still another meeting was needed by him. However, this period it was different things than the primary one. For obtaining the unique providers of the take women the customers feel incredibly met constantly appear. The companion in Mumbai have groups and distinct sections. The amount of money compensated for an in-call support consistently assures final results and productive that is fantastic results for every customer and each. Carolina Cover Girls possess a higher level of type and sophistication suitable for just about any event. They're professionals and will willingly go to great lengths to make sure you get the best dating experience you deserve and crave.
Visit our website:
Mumbai Escorts
Mumbai Escorts agency
Female Escorts Service In Mumbai
Mumbai Escort agency
Mumbai Escorts Service

Aarvi Mehtha said...

Among the finest and earliest Goa Escort services, Wet N Wild Escorts continues to be supplying quality female comrades that are exceptional to Goa business travelers and natives . Service record and our outstanding reviews discusses for itself. Having a collection Escorts that are as substantial, there are many to decide on from and our choice of female comrades grows. Even company traveling customers and most of our Chicago hobbyists customers are repeat customers to get a motive. Wet N Wild Escorts does its best to service customer for customers with specific disability needs using the finest Chicago escorts. We provide you the possibility to satisfy with amazing and wonderful Chicago escorts as well as our only goal is joy and your happiness.
Goa Escorts
Goa Escorts Service
female Escorts In Goa
Independent Goa Escort
Goa Escort

Kitty Singh said...

Our independent escorts are here to go with you and to serve you the real life girl friend. Our escorts are here to please you with their company. All of the girls are associated with us are from high profile and prosperous families and want to live life by their own.
Nainital Escorts , Independent Delhi Escorts , Bangalore Escorts , Goa Escorts , Jaipur Escorts , Haldwani Escorts , Mumbai Escorts

Unknown said...

If you are one of those who arrive to Jaipur with an aim to do something unique, then feel free to call me because I also love doing such things that can satisfy both you and me. For enjoying titillating encounters, I am completely safe and reliable for that. I can travel with you along the city and come with you at your place.
Look Beautiful and sensual Model:-
Dehradun Escorts
Gurgaon Escort
Nainital Escorts
Jaipur Escorts
Goa Escorts
Jaipur Escorts
Mumbai Escorts

My Delhi Escort said...

Escorts are safe in both ways. It will be safer for a client to hire an escort than a prostitute.
Delhi Escorts

Unknown said...

we provide our escorting services, once it is about looking your approaching or current place gathering & festivity in Jodhpur. Our escorts can allow you to feel that the bit of achievement, as a result of they'll give a good probability of attraction, and you'll grow to be the foremost contributor of any placing deal.
Goa Escorts
Jaipur Escorts
Jodhpur Escorts
Goa Call Girls
Jaipur Call Girls
Nainital Call Girls
Dehradun Escorts

sharemarketprofile39 said...

Superb blog. When I saw Jon’s email, I know the post will be good and I am surprised that you wrote it man!
We are the best Share Market training academy in Chennai, offering best stock market trading and technical analysis training online & live classes. Enroll now for share market classes by today.for more details contact us: +91 95858 44338, +91 95669 77791

delhi celebrity escort said...

Very Nice Thanks For Sharing